Girl Power! And Other Renegade Ideas | Rebel Sisters by Marita Conlon-McKenna

Upon finishing Rebel Sisters by Marita Conlon-McKenna, I was filled with regret that I didn’t pay better attention in the British Literature class I took my sophomore year of college. The class surveyed Romantic, Victorian, and Modern literature. I happily devoured Romantic literature, which was a reaction to the Industrial Revolution and Age of Enlightenment, and it celebrated nature, spirituality, individuality, creativity, and purity. It’s something that resonated with me, and now that I think about it, that’s probably why I’m so keen on the Steampunk subculture; it seems to celebrate many of the same things. Victorian literature and Modern literature? Puh! That stuff could hardly hold my attention. And…now I find that unfortunate because we definitely studied the Irish identity in Modern literature, and that is a major theme in Rebel Sisters. While I enjoyed this novel, I feel I could have experience a different plane of appreciation had I just applied myself a little harder in that class.

Rebel SistersRebel Sisters by Marita Conlon-McKenna

Released: January 2016
Publisher: Transworld Ireland
Add to Goodreads
★★★☆☆

Growing up in the privileged confines of Dublin’s leafy Rathmines, the bright, beautiful Gifford sisters Grace, Muriel and Nellie kick against the conventions of their wealthy Anglo-Irish background and their mother Isabella’s expectations. Soon, as World War I erupts across Europe, the spirited sisters find themselves caught up in their country’s struggle for freedom.

Muriel falls deeply in love with writer Thomas MacDonagh, artist Grace meets the enigmatic Joe Plunkett – both leaders of ‘The Rising’ – while Nellie joins the Citizen Army and bravely takes up arms, fighting alongside Countess Constance Markievicz in the rebellion.

On Easter Monday, 1916, the biggest uprising in Ireland for two centuries begins. The world of the Gifford sisters and everyone they hold dear will be torn apart in a fight that is destined for tragedy.


It helps to do a little research before reading this book

I would always encourage readers to do some research before or while reading a historical fiction novel to help put things into context. Even if I’m already familiar with a historical topic (for example: WWII), I always have my phone nearby so I can do a quick scroll through a wikipedia page to learn more about a person or an event or an idea. I even found myself briefly referring to Wikipedia while reading the Mistresses of Versailles novels just so I could understand the subtle cultural references even though they usually didn’t play a major role in the story. Rebel Sisters, on the other hand, required a little light reading before digging in to its pages…and then some more reading once I hit page 200.

This is the second novel I’ve read this year that has made me realize how very little I learned (or was taught) in my high school history courses. I’ve determined that if an event or nation or idea didn’t affect America is some way, it wasn’t mentioned in the pages of my AP World History textbook (and I’m convinced that the reason so many pages were dedicated to China had less to do with its rich history and more to do with that fact that China was emerging as a superpower). I’m wracking my brain to remember if Ireland ever made it in to the textbooks pages…maybe there was one paragraph on the Great Potato Famine being related to an increase in Irish immigrants in America?

For the record, I think Marita Conlon-McKenna actually does an exceptional job at writing about the political atmosphere of Ireland during the early 1900s in a fashion that is not daunting and is easy to understand for newcomers of the topic. However, I found myself quite interested in the events that lead up to the rebellion so I could better understand the characters’ motivation. So…my recent search history looks like this:

  • Irish identity in literature
  • Irish cultural nationalism
  • Irish Home Rule Movement
  • Partition of Ireland
  • Bloody Sunday (Ireland has like… four of them)
  • The Cranberries (mostly because I just like their music, but they did reference the Easter Rising in Zombie)
  • Rockall (nothing to do with the story, but I was intrigued by the name. Turns out, it’s an “islet” [tiny island], but literally it’s a gigantic rock, and apparently there have been disputes between Ireland and the UK over whose rock islet it is)

The Gifford Sisters are kind of amazing

First off, all six of the Gifford sisters accomplished pretty incredible things in their lifetime; they were journalists, broadcasters, artists, nurses, nationalist and suffrage activists. Basically, this book exudes girl power. (Oh yea, PS, I forgot to mention that the Gifford sisters are real!!!) However, Rebel Sisters mostly revolves around Muriel, Grace, and Nellie, who were the most involved in the rebellion. Conlon-McKenna weaves this wonderful story about these three young women growing up, falling in love, starting families…yet also engaging in a revival of a culture, challenging social norms for women, publishing politically-charged drawings and journal articles, and participating in a rebellion. All in a days work.

The challenges of writing about real people are this…

I can’t help but bring up the Sisters of Versailles by Sally Christie. I think because the Mailly-Nesle sisters are not as well-known as say… Madame de Pompadour and Comtesse de Barry, Christie was allowed more creative license in breathing life into the characters of the five sisters. However, when your characters are Irish nationalist icons from the past 100 years…I suspect you’re only allowed so much. Between that and the subject matter, Rebel Sisters was a much…drier read. Actually, I don’t know if “dry” is even the appropriate adjective because that suggests the book was boring, and it definitely wasn’t that. But I didn’t feel as engaged as I had hoped either. As much as I admired the Gifford sisters, I didn’t form an attachment with them.

The story also spanned 16 years in 400 pages, so I felt like I was only given brief glimpses into certain parts of the sisters’ lives. And, the parts that I wanted more of seemed to pass by too quickly– for example, the actual Easter Rising and resolution took place in the last 60 pages of the book.

Overall, I quite enjoyed this book, but I also wanted more. To try to tell three different stories that take place over 16 years in only 400 pages…it’s almost too ambitious. I can’t decide if I wanted the story to be more focused on one of the sisters or if I just wanted more pages/books so I could get to know the three sisters better.

TLC Book Tours

I received a copy of the Rivals of Versailles for free in exchange for an honest review. The thoughts are ever my own.
Advertisements

Posted by

Twenty-something. Michigander. Bookkeeper by day, superhero and blogger by night. Some of my favorite things include: travel, the Japanese language, photography, video games, sweater-weather, and of course books and tea. The Harry Potter books are my favorite, and I can never have too much peppermint tea.

4 thoughts on “Girl Power! And Other Renegade Ideas | Rebel Sisters by Marita Conlon-McKenna

  1. Wonderful review! Also tell me about it – in regards to history courses. I hated history in high-school precisely because it was always about a list of facts and battles and kings and I could never remember the order. But I’ve learned so much from historical fiction about how people lived, their culture and customs, and then eventually sought out history books of my own interest. I love fiction as the initial spark to get me interested in a topic 🙂

    Like

  2. Like you I love researching more about a topic as I read. In my case, I’ve already done a ton of research on this era in Irish history because it impacted my own ancestors. This book is definitely going on my TBR list – it’s right up my alley!

    Thanks for being a part of the tour.

    Like

  3. I haven’t read a lot of historical books, but I can see how it can be nice to look something up now and then. Although on the other hand I can imagine if I have to do that often it might get me out of the book. But it can be neat to know a bit more about the topic the book is about.Here we learn mostly history about Europe and then focused on east Europe. During our later years we got a course about America and I loved it so much I took a course American history during university. We also got a topic about Indonesia, but the Netherlands colonized that, so that still had some sort of connection with the Netherlands. It’s too bad how most countries focus mostly on their own history, although I guess that makes sense, but it’s interesting to learn more about other countries as well. There are quite some countries I know very little about their history. It’s too bad it was a bit dry at times and I can imagine it feels like you’re only getting glimpses of their lives if the book span so much time. Great review!

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s